Exclusive

Ayr rapist Steven Maclean guilty of crimes against six women

The offender will be sentenced later for his crimes <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
The offender will be sentenced later for his crimes (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

FOR more than a decade, women described living in fear of Steven Maclean. One called the relationship a "horror show". Another cried through a rape. It was only when police smashed into his Ayr home and discovered a distressed victim that his long trail of abuse finally unravelled.

A jury at the High Court in Paisley has now convicted the 36-year-old of 15 offences spanning 14 years, involving six former partners.

Maria Avarl said she did not know Susan Alexander worked at Paisley Sheriff Court until she went there on June 10, 2025The High Court trial was heard at Paisley (Image: Newsquest)

Unanimous

The jury of 13 found him unanimously guilty of 13 charges, and guilty by a majority on two more.

He was only cleared of two additional allegations.

His crimes started in February 2010 and only ended on December 15, 2024 when police burst into his home.

In the two years he was dating one victim, he had had sex with someone under the age of 16.

He also hit her face, spat on her, persistently contacted her by phone and text, monitored her movements, and insisted on accompanying her and following her when with friends.

That abusive behaviour was mirrored with the other victims.

In his closing statement for the case, the Crown's advocate depute said a "highly compelling" picture emerged.

Whether Maclean's relationships lasted "years, months or days", there was physical and sexual abuse, he said.

'Not a nice person'

A childhood friend of the first victim "saw how possessive" the man was and "how she changed when with him" as well as physical marks.

The victim described Maclean as "not a nice person".

The prosecutor said when he put to the accused that he was a domestic abuser, "he agreed with that".

The victim's first assault was while they were watching the TV programme Shameless.

Maclean then "made it feel like it was her fault".

He questioned who one victim had been with, then used the information against her to make her feel guilty, he told the jury.

She would "take her mind to a different place simply to get herself through it".

Maclean served a period in prison in 2012, during which the victim had written to him.

The prosecutor said the woman described herself as "young, naive and looking for something she didn't get at home".

"She still thought the accused might change," he told the jury.

"But we know he did not change at all."

Threats and physical violence

Like the first survivor of Maclean, another victim was subjected to threats of violence against her and members of her family.

And he threw a pot and its contents towards her in 2022.

It was only a first date.

Another single date was similar in August 2024, where he shouted, swore, and uttered offensive and threatening remarks towards a different victim.

In 2023, he subjected another partner to persistent calls and messages, controlled who she socialised with, shouted, swore, uttered offensive and abusive remarks, locked the door and held her against her will, and repeatedly struck her to the face.

Four of the victims said Maclean was having sex with them at the same time in 2024.

The jury convicted for three of those charges.

'Horror show'

One of those women said the relationship was a "horror show", heard the court.

She was "scared all the time".

Maclean was described as always checking her phone, controlling what make-up and clothes she could wear.

The woman took the blame for a collision he caused.

He was charged with seizing her face and the steering wheel, causing the vehicle to hit a wall.

Then he took her phone to prevent her reporting it.

He was described by the witness as threatening to "punch her teeth down her throat" - so she took the blame.

"The pattern of threatening, controlling and coercive behaviour can be seen throughout," said the advocate depute.

One witness said she saw Maclean with a woman and called police anonymously.

The next day, police knocked on and then forced the door, finding her with Maclean.

The victim only described the rape after the attacker had been removed from the home by police.

At the time, he was already on three bail orders from 2024 for charges that would eventually be combined into the High Court case.

The Crown said police witnesses described the victim's distress after they forced entry to Maclean's property.

A neighbour had heard "disturbances" from the victim and accused.

'Switch being thrown'

The jury was told: "All spoke to him changing very quickly, like a switch being thrown.

"Others describe him as volatile and unpredictable. Most speak to [him being] possessive and demanding. There's a clear pattern of criminal behaviour."

The advocate depute said there was a line from Maclean's domestic abuse to his sexual abuse.

"He took that step when he assaulted [Victim A] and ended when he assaulted [Victim F]," said the prosecutor.

"The evidence supports the conclusion that individual incidents are composite parts of a course of conduct."

Michael Anderson KC, representing Maclean, told the jury: "I don't ask you to like him.

"This is not a court of morals, and that's probably lucky for Mr Maclean."

But he said witnesses spoke to there being "drink, drugs and the passage of time" that would allow reasonable doubt.

And he said the fact that one victim did not engage with the justice system meant the jury could not test how "credible and reliable" her evidence was.

"If any evidence puts reasonable doubt in your mind in relation to any allegations, you are duty bound to acquit," he said.

The jury disagreed.

After convicting him of 15 of 17 charges, presiding Judge John Neil McCormick deferred sentence until October 29.

Maclean, who appeared from custody throughout, remains a prisoner at Barlinnie.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos