Sheriff court

Donnan Construction fined after worker fell through roof

Stranraer-based Donnan Construction <i>(Image: Street View)</i>
Stranraer-based Donnan Construction (Image: Street View)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A CONSTRUCTION company must pay out more than £17,000 after a teenage worker suffered serious injuries from a fall at a South Ayrshire site.

Donnan Construction Limited was fined after the firm admitted failing to ensure the health, safety and welfare at work of employees.

The company admitted failing to make a suitable and sufficient risk assessment for the health and safety of employees while working from a great height at High Ballochdowan Farm, Ballantrae.

They admitted failing to provide a safe system for employees to work at height whilst cleaning gutters at a barn at the premises.

The firm failed to provide adequate instruction and supervision, with one worker accessing a fragile roof while cleaning the gutters of a barn.

He then fell through the roof to the ground, to his severe injury and permanent impairment.

A procurator fiscal depute told Ayr Sheriff Court: "On May 12, 2023 the 19-year-old fell through the roof while cleaning gutters of a barn. His colleague was on the roof without any measure preventing this.

"The company was incorporated in George Street, Dumfries and has nine employees, in construction work in agricultural business.

"The roof was at a slight angle with corrugated cement.

"They went onto the roof as they were unable to complete it using ladders.

"The cement broke, falling 4.7 metres.

"He was taken to Galloway Community Hospital, then Queen Elizabeth University Hospital with a fractured pelvis and severe nerve damage to his right leg. Doctors operated on his abdomen.

"He was taken back to Galloway Community Hospital. On his right foot he currently wears a walking boot to assist him. He has severe, persistent nerve problem. He is not working and not sure what roles are available for future employment."

The firm's defence solicitor said: "From the outset I wish to express my client's regret and remorse for the injuries. The matter was taken very seriously.

"It appears there were no previous incidents in the 35 years previous and no injuries, and no further incidents were noted.

"The company would not have instructed this, but accepts overall responsibility.

"Lessons have been learned."

Sheriff Michael Meehan suggested "there is a sense of victim blaming", but Mr McDonald added: "They accept full responsibility, there is no blame whatsoever."

When the case called for sentencing on Thursday, Sheriff Meehan said: "None of the workers saw any documentation.

"A risk assessment is futile if not shared with those completing the task.

"These are steps that should have been taken at the time. By way of mitigation, the company accepted responsibility from the outset and deep regret that the company's failings led to him sustaining severe injuries.

"It is accepted by the company that had the work been properly planned in advance, it would have identified risks - these steps should have been taken at the time and the risks would not have been there.

"There is a very human cost in this case."

The company was fined £16,000 plus a victim surcharge payment to the Scottish Government of £1,200.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos