Sheriff court

Woman back in court after impersonating husband in fraud bid

Karen Lawrence returned to Ayr Sheriff Court <i>(Image: Charlie Gilmour)</i>
Karen Lawrence returned to Ayr Sheriff Court (Image: Charlie Gilmour)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A WOMAN who pretended to be her husband over the phone in a £100k credit card and mortgage fraud returned to court - after being 'taken in by an online romance scam' and then stealing the sum.

Karen Lawrence previously pleaded guilty at a pre-trial hearing at Ayr Sheriff Court, as her lawyer revealed that the money was taken from her partner after she fell victim to an online dating fraud herself.

The 66-year-old was warned that custody was at the forefront of the sheriff's mind, with sentencing deferred for further health enquiries.

Lawrence admitted forming a fraudulent scheme to obtain money at an address in Burnside Drive, Dalrymple and elsewhere in Scotland between February 18, 2019 and February 28, 2020.

Karen Lawrence (Image: Charlie Gilmour)

She admitted contacting Precise Mortgages by telephone, adopting the voice of a male and pretending that she was her husband.

Prosecutors had claimed that Lawrence arranged a valuation of and listed for sale the property jointly owned by her and her husband, and "on the strength of said valuation utter as genuine a mortgage application form to said Precise Mortgages", with his name borne to be signed as signatory, securing a loan for £54,557.47.

She then contacted Fidelity Pension by telephone, again adopting a male voice, and pretended she was her husband on various occasions from October 11 to November 15, 2019.

She "uttered as genuine" two pension withdrawal application forms to the firm from November 20 to December 22, 2019, securing a pension withdrawal totalling £45,101.68.

Further allegations in the charge and the total sums taken in the fraud previously reported on the Crown's indictment were amended in a plea deal with prosecutors.

She pleaded guilty to a second charge that she "uttered as genuine" a mortgage application form, pension withdrawal paperwork, and loan applications with her husband's signature being forged on May 25, 2019 at Burnside Drive and elsewhere.

Sheriff Siobhan Connelly had deferred sentencing for criminal justice social work reports and restriction of liberty order assessment.

Bail had been continued for Lawrence, of Innellan Drive, Kilmarnock, with a non-harassment order put in place in the meantime.

When she appeared in the dock in January, her defence advocate Lewis Kennedy KC said: "She has no history of offending behaviour.

"She is unlikely again to engage in such behaviour.

"She has led a pro-social life. She has a steady, stable history in work as a community care nurse for 20 years.

"She accepts full responsibility for her own actions.

"She is now 66, a first offender, and victim herself of an online romance scam.

"She was manipulated by this fraudster and thought she was involved in a real relationship. She did not personally benefit from this venture.

"It was not financially driven and had significant personal loss, she sent the scammer £50,000 of her own savings.

"She is now heavily indebted and lost her relationship with her own daughter. Her husband remains the primary victim. She is nevertheless a victim.

"Alcohol abuse and feeling isolated made her more susceptible to the romance scam.

"She expresses significant regret for this offence and the significant impact on the victim, her husband, and substantial shame for the scam."

Sentencing was deferred for four weeks after 'significant health concerns' were flagged in reports.

Sheriff Connelly said: "This is a serious matter and custody is in the forefront of the court's mind."

When she appeared in court again on February 24, Mr Kennedy said his client was "due for a further follow-up appointment at Crosshouse Hospital" and requested sentence be further deferred.

Bail was continued and she will face sentencing again next month.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos